WeChat

WeChat

U.S. Court Requires Disclosure of Expert Witness AI Prompts: AI Usage Records May Become Litigation Evidence

U.S. Court Requires Disclosure of Expert Witness AI Prompts: AI Usage Records May Become Litigation Evidence

A U.S. court's reported requirement for an expert witness to disclose AI prompts highlights the growing importance of artificial intelligence usage records, expert accountability, and litigation evidence management.

1. Case Background: AI Use by an Expert Witness Raises Disclosure Questions

According to a Reuters report dated November 20, 2026, a U.S. federal court in Connecticut addressed the use of artificial intelligence by an expert witness in an environmental litigation case.

Case Name: Conservation Law Foundation Inc. v. Shell Oil Products US et al.

Case Number: 3:21-cv-00933-VDO

The matter concerns the expert witness's use of AI tools in connection with the litigation and the potential disclosure of prompts entered into those tools.

This development highlights an important issue for businesses, law firms, and professional consultants: when AI is used to prepare expert reports, analyze evidence, or assist in developing professional opinions, records of that use may become relevant to litigation discovery and judicial review.

Importantly, this is a case-specific development. It should not be interpreted as establishing a general rule that all AI prompts must be disclosed in every U.S. lawsuit.

2. Why Could AI Prompts Become Litigation Evidence?

AI prompts are the instructions, questions, or information that users submit to artificial intelligence systems.

In litigation, prompts and AI-generated outputs may become relevant to several issues:

  1. Independent Expert Judgment: Whether the expert independently developed the opinions expressed in the report.

  2. Influence of AI: Whether AI materially influenced the expert's analysis or conclusions.

  3. Source Verification: What information or materials were used by the AI system.

  4. Reliability of Findings: Whether AI-generated content contained inaccurate, incomplete, or unverified information.

  5. Professional Accountability: Whether the expert independently reviewed and verified the AI-generated material.

Where AI tools contribute to the preparation of an expert report, relevant usage records may help establish how the expert's conclusions were developed.

However, whether specific prompts must be disclosed depends on the applicable court orders, procedural and evidentiary rules, case circumstances, and any relevant protections for privileged communications, attorney work product, confidential information, and trade secrets.

3. Implications for U.S. Businesses and Cross-Border Litigation

This development is particularly relevant to companies, law firms, accounting firms, engineering consultants, and professional expert organizations that use AI in their operations.

A. Expert Reports and Professional Opinions

When engaging experts to prepare technical, financial, environmental, or engineering reports, businesses should clearly define the permitted use of AI tools and the responsibility for human review.

B. Litigation Evidence and Document Management

Organizations should establish appropriate AI usage recordkeeping procedures, including the retention of relevant prompts, generated outputs, document revisions, and human review records.

C. Protection of Confidential Information and Trade Secrets

Businesses should avoid entering client information, litigation strategies, personal data, and confidential commercial information into public AI platforms without proper authorization and safeguards.

D. Responsibilities of Lawyers and Experts

AI should remain an assisting tool. It does not replace the independent professional judgment and verification responsibilities of lawyers, expert witnesses, or corporate professionals.

4. How Should Businesses Establish AI Governance?

CACC recommends that businesses consider implementing five essential management mechanisms:

  1. AI Authorization Policy: Define which employees and professionals are authorized to use AI tools and for what purposes.

  2. Prompt Management: Establish guidelines for entering information into AI systems according to the sensitivity of the relevant materials.

  3. Data Confidentiality Controls: Prevent unauthorized disclosure of client information, personal data, and commercial secrets.

  4. Human Review Procedures: Require qualified professionals to review important legal opinions, expert reports, and AI-generated findings.

  5. Evidence Preservation: Maintain appropriate records of AI usage, document versions, and review procedures to support traceability and accountability.

5. CACC International Law Firm – Legal and AI Governance Services

As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into corporate operations, legal services, and cross-border investments, AI governance is becoming an essential component of corporate risk management.

CACC International Law Firm can assist businesses with the development and review of the following frameworks:

  • AI Agent Governance Review: Governance and accountability reviews for AI agents.

  • AI Litigation Governance: Legal risk management for AI use in litigation.

  • AI Evidence Management: AI-related evidence preservation and documentation procedures.

  • Data Privacy & Confidentiality: Data protection and confidentiality compliance.

  • AI Vendor Contract Review: Legal review of AI service provider agreements.

  • AI Risk & Compliance Assessment: Corporate AI risk and regulatory compliance assessments.

6. CACC Legal Perspective

Artificial intelligence can improve business efficiency, but it may also change how evidence is created, reviewed, and challenged in litigation.

Businesses should recognize that AI-generated content is not automatically accurate, and AI usage records are not automatically protected by legal confidentiality or privilege.

This is particularly important in cross-border litigation, expert witness reporting, internal corporate investigations, and regulatory proceedings.

Establishing an AI governance framework that is traceable, verifiable, and accountable will help businesses manage legal exposure, protect confidential information, and strengthen compliance across international operations.

About CACC

CACC ASEAN Legal Advisory Group supports individuals, international businesses, and investors with Cambodia-related criminal legal matters, land transactions and disputes, corporate compliance, cross-border investment, and commercial legal advisory, coordinating appropriately qualified local professionals as required.

Cross-Border Legal, Investment, and Business Solutions

CACC also advises on legal and regulatory matters relating to ASEAN market entry, AI data centers, GPU computing infrastructure, power infrastructure, and battery energy storage projects, with an emphasis on lawful and transparent business structures.

Connect Through the Contact Icons on the Right

For legal or business advisory inquiries, click the Telegram, WhatsApp, Messenger, or LINE icon on the right-hand side of this page. Briefly describe the location, nature of the matter, and assistance requested.

CACC International Law Firm | CACC ASEAN Legal Advisory Group

CACC ASEAN Legal Advisory Group
Legal • Investment • Business Solutions for the AI Era



Disclaimer: This article is provided for general legal information and business risk awareness only. It does not constitute legal advice concerning any specific matter. Actual disclosure obligations depend on applicable laws, court orders, procedural rules, and the facts of each case.